Monday, 15 December 2008

Women in adverts


Noticeably all the adverts are selling food and cleaning products as a woman’s traditional role is to be a housewife which these adverts conform to. Shockingly, pizza advert uses a blunt portrayal of the division of labour with the women being subject to her husband’s dominance. Her husband orders her yelling ‘chop chop’ to make a pizza and she gleefully makes it despites his rude attitude towards her. Stark contrast between the hard working rushed of her feet women and her lay about television junky man but the advert depicts these opposing positions as socially acceptable.

Sex objects

During the montage a modestly dressed young women rips of her skirt when she spills drink on it. It positions her from a formal woman to a sex object, maintaining that women are simply there to serve men.

Similarly, at the beginning of the adverts a women is attempting to fit in her jeans but she has clearly put on weight. Therefore she will have to diet in order to please her man- suggesting that women should satisfy their men and live up to men’s expectations.

Housewives (adverts include tide, whirlpool, hovers, Mr Muscle etc)
In one of the adverts a child drops the drink but as she goes to clean it the mum says ‘’It’s alright, I’ll clean up’’. Women are consistently being shown as domestic Goddesses that are satisfied with their role as house slave. These adverts are also inaccurate as they assume that all women stay at work and ignore the fact that an increasing number of women are now in paid labour and this figure is rising dramatically. Despite the family offering to assist the mum in hamburger helper as they say ‘’let’s give mum a hand’’. However, it is ‘mum’ who is doing the chores and is the leader whilst it is the other family member that help. Although ‘mum’ has full responsibility nobody offer to do the chores for her.

Stereotypes like multi-tasking are also displayed in the advert whilst the women is hovering she is carrying her baby. The ideal woman is illustrated as superhuman and somewhat flawless. The underlying message further exemplifies that perfection equals being a domestic Godesses and submissive to your partner; which the female voice encourages by telling women to behave in this manner.

Unusually even in cleaning adverts patriarchy is being promoted as the women is told by the controlling male voice over ‘’You’ll never clean the same way again’’ Mr Muscle rescues her from the burdens of cleaning. Even in areas that are considers a women’s domain it is men that teach women the way succeed.



The lighting mainly focuses the models breast to enlarge them and make the model appear more curvaceous. Moreover, dehumanisation ignores the women’s contributions and intellectual capacity to portray them in an animalistic manner, for instance the women liking the floor. The faceless women does not allow them to have an identity and groups them as all the same.

Key quotations
’We are exposed to over 2,000 adverts a day, constituting perhaps the most educational force in society’- Jean Kilbourne

‘In an extremely competitive environment, you kind of go back to T & A (tits and ass)’’- Bugle Boy clothes publicists

‘We often find no representational connections in contemporary advertising. One of the common registers of print advertising is of the naked or sexually-posed woman selling a product’- cf. Lazier Smith 1989, Furham and Bitar 1993.

‘Clearly, the construction of masculinity involves a dual defamation of women as sex objects and a maintenance of male sexual superiority.’- cf Hood 1995

Turkish delight also draws on typecast to sell the product. Props theory is applicable to this advertisement, the women is waiting for her prince to rescue her whilst she is stuck in the desert (damsel in distress). Therefore, the man is the Proppian hero whilst the woman is the Proppian princess; a direct binary opposition is being displayed which mirrors patriarchal ideologies. The central focus of the advert is the woman’s face which the camera often subject to close-ups again her main purpose is to be ‘eye candy’. Continuous shots focusing on her eyes relate to the idea of mysteriousness which is significant as it is correlates to the Arabian theme.



Shake and vac uses obvious stereotypes of women to sell their product. The way the woman prances and cleans reflects the notion of multi-tasking; suggesting that the ideal housewife can do everything at once. Stereotypically, bursting into song is associated with women as it represents femininity implicitly indicating that perfection means living up to generalisations about females. Although the women is wearing modest attire her jives and beauty highlight that her only purpose is to serve as ‘eye candy’ because she is being projected through the male gaze (Laura Mulvey). Constant zooms on her legs further exemplify her objectification because the central focus is her body. Lastly, her blonde hair conveys a ditzy persona and despite the absence of men their presence is still felt as her cleaning ritual is ultimately to please her husband.

Tuesday, 2 December 2008

Femme fatale

Femme fatale rejects traditional portrays of women and are a direct on the nuclear family. She refuses to be a dutiful wife and has no aspirations to be married as marriage to her closes off excitement often being sexless and loveless. As Janey Place points out, "She is not often won over and pacified by love for the hero, as is the strong heroine of the forties who is significantly less sexual than the film noir woman." Highlight the double standards whilst women must be outstandingly attractive it is the unconventional looking man that she falls for. Similar to Disney the woman’s appearance is vital and she must appear to be flawless.

She remains fiercely independent even when faced with her own destruction. And in spite of her inevitable death, she leaves behind the image of a strong, exciting, and unrepentant woman who defies the control of men and rejects the institution of the family. Enchanted (2007) also has an inevitable ending however it often results in the ‘evil’ characters death rather than protagonist yet the message is clear the ‘whore’ always dies leaving behind the innocent virginal character.

Classic femme fatale resorts to murder to free herself from an unbearable relationship with a man who would try to possess and control her, as if she were a piece of property or a pet. According to Sylvia Harvey, the women of film noir are "[p]resented as prizes, desirable objects". Although women are indirectly sexualised they remain the trophy for the man with little focus placed upon her intelligence. Often it is the man enticing the women but she is labelled as the ‘bad one’. Edward in Enchanted also lures Giselle to break the traditional story of a princes getting the princess however, Giselle is not punished because ultimately she is a virgin.

They feel trapped by husbands or lovers who treat them as "standard equipment" and by an institution — marriage — that makes such treatment possible. Marriage for the femme fatale is associated with unhappiness, boredom, and the absence of romantic love and sexual desire. In some films, the husband's lack of interest in his wife seems almost sadistic. Despite men being in control of women in Disney films they are put on a pedestal and respected in contrast to the poor treatment of femme fatale’s.

Another sign of the sterility of film noir marriages is the absence of children produced by these marriages. Childless couples are far more common in film noir than the traditional father-mother-children nuclear family. However, Disney films depict women with installed maternal instincts and imply that after marriage they conceive bt Enchanted (200) sees Giselle becoming a step-mother. It is possible that Enchanted (2007) is challenging traditional stereotypes as she is a ‘’good’ step-mother but also fits in with the diversity of modern families.
The family home only intensifies this atmosphere of coldness and entrapment for the married femme fatale. The lighting and mise-en-scène of the family home contribute further to its image as a trap whereas the bright spacious apartment in Enchanted (2007) exemplifies Giselle’s freedom.

Noir films create this image of the strong, unrepressed woman, and then attempt to contain it by destroying the femme fatale or converting her to traditional womanhood. Her determination to change often leads to her death and like Disney implies that we are born with certain characteristics that we can not change. She refuses to be defined by the male hero or submit her sexuality to the male-dominated institution of the family; instead, she defines herself and resists all efforts by the hero to "put her in her place." Akin to this Giselle never changes herself to impress Edward which is partly the reason he feel in love with her.

The explicit messages of film noir seem to be clear regarding women and the family: Women who transgress the boundaries of conventional family life meet with and deserve the most extreme punishment, and the men who fall victim to their sexual charms meet a similar fate. The simplistic message is also echoed by Disney that if a character goes against stereotypes they are severely punished and good always triumphs over evil.

It could also be argued that the Femme fatale never achieves ultimate control because she dies and uses her sexuality to lure men. Similar to Disney’s women’s intellectual attributes are ignored. However, the duplicity nature of the women highlights intelligence unlike the passive Giselle. Overall, ‘evil’ women are always punished whilst the innocent character is rewarded no matter what the genre.

Monday, 1 December 2008

Disney accused by Catholic cleric of corrupting children's minds

A leading Catholic cleric has launched a fierce attack on Disney, claiming it has corrupted children and encouraged greed.












Christopher Jamison, the Abbot of Worth in West Sussex, has accused the corporation of "exploiting spirituality" to sell its products and of turning Disneyland into a modern day pilgrimage site.

He argues that it pretends to provide stories with a moral message, but has actually helped to create a more materialistic culture.

Corporations and industries have benefited from promoting false notions of fulfillment. Disney he says is "a classic example" of how consumerism is being sold as an alternative to finding happiness in traditional morality.

While he acknowledges that Disney stories carry messages showing good triumphing over evil, he argues this is part of a ploy to persuade people that they should buy Disney products in order to be "a good and happy family".

"The message behind every movie and book, behind every theme park and T-shirt is that our children's world needs Disney," he says. "So they absolutely must go to see the next Disney movie, which we'll also want to give them on DVD as a birthday present. "They will be happier if they live the full Disney experience; and thousands of families around the world buy into this deeper message as they flock to Disneyland." He continues: "This is the new pilgrimage that children desire, a rite of passage into the meaning of life according to Disney. "Where once morality and meaning were available as part of our free cultural inheritance, now corporations sell them to us as products." "Once planted there they can make us endlessly greedy. And that is exactly what they are doing."

The Walt Disney Company, founded in 1923 by brothers Walt and Roy Disney, is one of the world's biggest entertainment companies. It owns 11 theme parks and several television networks, while its Hollywood studios have produced more than 200 feature films.

Similar to my research Jamieson explores the notion that Disney has an underlying message which it conceals through the overly joyful innocent characters. However, whilst Jamieson examines the capitalist message I am analysing patriarchal ideology. Nevertheless Jamieson is a critique of the way Disney feed children corrupt message. He even goes as far as to say that secularization is due to Disney ignoring religion and celebrating wealth.

By Jonathan Wynne-Jones, Religious Affairs Correspondent
Source:http://www.telegraph.co.uk

Monday, 24 November 2008

"Disney Is Not Sexist" by Susie Kopecky,

In the opinion piece, the Disney label came under fire for alleged subliminal sexism. It was argued that the classic Disney movies of the last 70 years have been inherently sexist; I couldn’t disagree more.

In the 20th century, Disney was called a revolutionary entertainer; in the 21st century, Disney is called sexist, up high in its ivory tower of misogyny. The great irony is how people seem to be missing the greater point: All of the classic Disney movies that we all grew up on, like Snow White, Sleeping Beauty and Cinderella, are character-driven stories. And more than that, they are uniquely female character-driven. With the exception of The Lion King, all of the highest grossing classic Disney movies are about women, and generally women who are significantly disadvantaged. The women of these stories are clever, and somehow manage to overcome great odds, sometimes with a little help from friends, and often with their own cunning. Therefore Disney is not a suppressive tool for women but it enables them to succeed in society which is said to be the main focus of the films.

In Disney’s Pocahontas, is it not Princess Pocahontas who saves John Smith and truly brings the term “roughing it” to new light? In Cinderella, the eponymous heroine has everything working against her: Her only ally is deceased, her step-mother and step-sisters are cruel and domineering, and she has no visible hope of ever raising herself up in society. And yet, her unflappable optimism and refusal to give in to cynicism (and a little help from her fairy godmother) are ultimately the keys that allow her to end up with everything she had ever dreamt of, and more. And don’t forget: Cinderella wanted a wonderful prince of a man (like every girl dreams of), but she wasn’t the one chasing the prince out of the ball, and she sure wasn’t the one making every woman in the kingdom try on a slipper made out of possibly the very worst material with which to construct a slipper, glass! Snow White is a very interesting story, as the drama entirely revolves around the beautiful, young Snow White and the beautiful (but crazy) Queen. Really, the prince of this story is little more than an afterthought; his only role is giving Snow White a kiss – yup, that’s about all. Of course, the message of love is celebrated, but the Prince has no direct impact on Snow White, as Snow White’s character is forged by her own life experiences, and her decisions to think positively, regardless of the fact that her only remaining family member wants nothing more than to see her dead.

Clearly, these stories never really happened, and there was never a Snow White to eat a poisoned apple. Such fables were constructed long ago to pass on a positive message of the endurance of the human (and perhaps specifically female) spirit, and the ability to change the playing field, even when the game appears set. In summary: The Disney women faced terrible odds, and through their positive character traits, intelligence, deep sense of humanity, understanding and innate cleverness and cunning, they triumphed. Even Peter Pan was not much of a hero until his contact with Wendy. Overall, the main message of Disney films is that men depend on women to succeed, without a female touch the men would be failures.

Ali Wachutka, The Transition From Individual to Sex Object

Jack Zipe a leading expert on fairy tales and German professor at the University of Minnesota, the movies have “a type of gender stereotyping . . . that has an adverse effect on children, in contrast to what parents think ... Parents think they’re essentially harmless – they are not harmless” (Giroux, “Roared” 103).

Maria Tatar, Harvard folklorist, also sees harm in the movies since “[Disney] capitalizes on the worst part of fairytales”. Maria clearly believes that the Disney films profit from unrealistic portrayals of characters i.e. the harmful gender roles being taught to young children. Moreover, they are placing the focus on the material world and removing the cunning and intelligent roles that the females once played (Healy). Female roles do not differ from one another but are all dulled down to glamorise the male position.

“People always talk about the ‘magic of Disney.’ Well, that’s the magic of Disney: it’s addictive. It’s like crack for 5-year-olds”(Healy). Disney ignores the pain and corruption of reality which they hide behind the innocent images. It acts as a false release for children and they become somewhat dependent on the films, they take away the troubles of life. Often when children come home from a long day at school they watch Disney films and this leads to comfort for them (similar to drugs) because it is so familiar.

Research done by Arthur Applebee has conclusively shown that “story characters become part of a child’s ‘real world’ and form part of their cultural heritage” (Zipes, “Preface” xii). Children become familiar with characters and begin to emulate their patterns of behaviour, girls want to be princesses and boys want to be price charming. Mean that according to uses and gratification theory young audiences use Disney films to form personal relationships but this can be rather damaging as the message being taught to children teaches racism, sexism and encourages capitalism.

Tatar also worries about the message the Disney movies present to young girls especially since they change the folk tales to express “the importance of beautiful dress and gorgeous good looks. Again society has become obsessed with image and this is further mirrored in Disney films. Possibly this could correlate to the rise in anorexia and low self body image amongst young people.

Disney opened their princess line in 2000 and in just one year they reached $300 million in sales, after three years their sales reached $2.5 billion (Healy). There is no doubt that they are reaching their target audience and their message is being made available to young children around the world. To Disney profit is vital and parents continue to purchase, as the corrupt ideals being put forward are very subtle and concealed by the cheerful tone. The corporation achieve their purpose to pass their values across by expanding the line through introducing dolls, clothes and other merchandise, literally there is no escaping temptation.

Snow White (1937) is one of the first recognised sexist films; her only emphasised qualities throughout the entire movie are her appearance and housekeeping skills. The evil queen is jealous of her because Snow White is the “fairest one of all” and the only reason the hunter, who was supposed to kill her, spares her life is because she is too pretty to kill. These scenes present the message that the greatest quality a woman can possess is beauty. It loses touch with females real assisted and implies that looks are the key to success, to an extent it is true and must be presentable to do well but beauty is not a necessity.

The filth and disorder of the cottage makes it apparent to Snow White that whoever lives in the house does not have a mother (Maio), because, after all, if they did, it would be the mother’s role to keep the house in order as that is a female’s one true calling in life. Women are domestic goddess in contrast to the incapable men. Disney’s version does so to a greater extent because they suggest that domestic chores are part of female nature.

Background Knowledge of Henry A Giroux

Unfortunately, the credibility of Henry A Giroux work can be questioned as he is widely known as a American cultural critic. Therefore he is overtly negative about his view towards America and American institutions. It has been argued that Disney has such a great influence over people as it shapes their mind from a young age and that the power is so great that they have emerged to become part of American culture. The preppy overtly happy clean innocent images being projected are supposed to represent American culture and foreign audiences believe this a true portrayal of Americanism. However, this is not the case but it teaches audience America is a promise land (American dream), Giroux is attacking this distort of reality.

Giroux has published more than 35 books and 300 academic articles, and is published widely throughout education and cultural studies literature. Thus, Giroux negative theory is due to his public anti- American culture beliefs.

Thursday, 20 November 2008

Racism in Disney




Racism is also prevalent in Disney films with racial generalisations being put forward in them. It is disguised through the use of animal characters such as the cats in Lady and the Tramp as they embody characteristics associated with Chinese people like slanted eyes. Yet it is so careful constructed that often it goes unnoticed, subtle racial stereotypes empower the white man like Tarzan who is the white heroic saviour whereas ethnic minorities are portrayed as strange or unpleasant. Automatically children learn that non-white citizens are corrupt individuals which is an outdated perception as it embraces the white saviours.

Disney somewhat celebrates Imperialism as the white man seems to dominate and tame other people i.e. Pocahontas. Interestingly, the original story of Pocahontas represented the historical mass assassination of Native Americans but Disney decided to distort the real story and make the white man the saviour whilst the Native Americans were depicted as the violent party. Their explanation for the alteration in the story is that they made its suitable for children by cutting out the violence. However, Disney never actually address the criticism implying that the films are rest and it is swept under the rug. Despite many complaining about the offence lyrics of the Aladdin song claiming it was discriminatory Disney kept them in but lowered the music.

As these powerful messages are exposed to many from a young age in effect Disney are responsible for the way a lot of people are socialised to behave. Thus, they maintain the ideology that white people are superior to other races and maintain their dominance.